US Supreme Court To Hear High-stakes Elections Case
Mohammad Ali (@ChaudhryMAli88) Published December 07, 2022 | 08:40 AM
Washington, Dec 7 (UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 7th Dec, 2022 ) :The US Supreme Court hears a case on Wednesday that could fundamentally alter the way democracy operates in America by expanding the power of state legislatures over elections for the White House and Congress.
The case, Moore v. Harper, would potentially give lawmakers in each of the 50 US states more authority in deciding who votes, where, and how in Federal elections.
The prospect has raised concerns on the left in a bitterly divided country still reeling from Donald Trump's refusal to accept the 2020 election results.
But it has also alarmed some on the right.
The case focuses on a theory known as the "independent state legislature" doctrine advanced by Republican lawmakers in the southern state of North Carolina.
Under the Constitution, the rules for federal elections are set by the state legislature.
"The Times, Places, and Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof," the Elections Clause says.
State legislatures have used their authority to map out congressional districts, set poll hours and agree on rules for voter registration and mail-in ballots.
Their laws have been subjected, however, to legal scrutiny by the local courts and possible veto by the state governor.
No longer, if the North Carolina lawmakers have their way.
In their brief to the nation's highest court, they say the Constitution "sets forth a detailed set of specific rights, specific procedures, and specific allocations of power.
"Here, those carefully drawn lines place the regulation of federal elections in the hands of state legislatures, Congress, and no one else." Amy Mason Saharia, a Washington lawyer who has argued a number of cases before the Supreme Court, said it "has never adopted that theory, but it has been floating around for a while" and the conservative-dominated court could embrace it.
North Carolina's Democratic governor Roy Cooper warned that "the court's decision on this alarming argument could fundamentally reshape American democracy.
"Our democracy is a fragile ecosystem that requires checks and balances to survive," Cooper wrote in an opinion piece published in The New York Times.
"Republican leaders in the North Carolina legislature have shown us how the election process can be manipulated for partisan gain," Cooper said.
"And that's what you can expect to see from state legislatures across the country if the court reverses course in this case." Moore v. Harper stems from an electoral dispute in North Carolina.
The 2020 census found that the state's population had increased, earning it an extra seat in the US House of Representatives.
North Carolina lawmakers redrew the congressional map to add a new district but the state supreme court threw it out in February, arguing that it favored Republicans by grouping Democrats in certain districts, diluting their vote.
A second map was also judged to be unfair and the state high court finally named an independent expert to carry out the redistricting.
North Carolina lawmakers appealed to the Supreme Court arguing that local courts were usurping their authority.
The Supreme Court declined to intervene right away and the map drawn up by the expert was used in November's midterm elections, resulting in seven House members from each party.
Democrats, from the state level to President Joe Biden, law professors and leading civil rights organizations have filed briefs urging the Supreme Court to reject the doctrine.
Sophia Lin Lakin of the American Civil Liberties Union warned of the dangers of an adverse ruling.
"An extreme interpretation of the US Constitution by the Supreme Court in this case will make it even easier for state legislators to suppress the vote, fraud, gerrymander election districts and potentially sabotage election results," she said.
The Republican Party dismissed the criticism as alarmist.
"Self-anointed constitutional law experts have convinced a healthy cross-section of armchair court watchers that, should the court decide this case the wrong way, it would signal the end of democracy," the National Republican Committee said in a brief. "Nonsense." A number of prominent conservatives did express concern.
"Our political system would suffer harm if partisan gerrymanders were left entirely without state-level checks and balances," said Arnold Schwarzenegger, the former Republican governor of California.
Related Topics
Recent Stories
Imad Wasim expected to take part in fourth T20I match against New Zealand
Ayubia chairlift closure inflicts heavy losses on traders
N. Macedonia starts elections that could decide stalled EU talks
Illegal occupation of land: Court confirms interim bail of PTI leader
Football: English Premier League result
Four dead as floods wreak havoc in Kenyan capital
PTI backed SIC nominates Hamid Raza for role of PAC chairman
Experts urge IMF, other finance institutions to ensure relief for growth in Paki ..
PM vows to work for country along with students
US ambassador meets Senate Chairman, discusses bilateral ties
Punjab govt allocated Rs 1 bln for providing motorbikes to students: Minister
Rupee sheds 02 paisa against dollar
More Stories From Miscellaneous
-
PDMA predicts gusty wind, rain with thunder, hails
23 hours ago -
Iranian president Raisi given guard of honour at PM House
2 days ago -
Intellectuals, writers accolades Naseer Mirza on his literary contribution
3 days ago -
Bahawalpur Adabi Sangat hosts memorable mushaira
3 days ago -
Cattle farming vital to alleviate poverty in rural areas
3 days ago -
Pakistan: A land of tourism, archeological wonders
3 days ago
-
Transforming education sector: from job hunters to job creators
5 days ago -
Amjad Bobby remembered on 19th death anniversary for timeless contributions to music
9 days ago -
Legendary actor Nadeem’s 26 films released on Eid-ul-Fitr days in 50 years
10 days ago -
Besant Hall Cultural Centre to celebrate evening with Sanam Marvi on 26 April
10 days ago -
Radio Bahawalpur presents program “Eidi Shidi”
13 days ago -
Radio Bahawalpur to broadcast Eid programs
15 days ago