Ex-South Africa Captain Smith Rejects Charges Of Racism
Zeeshan Mehtab Published December 17, 2021 | 09:53 PM
Graeme Smith, South Africa's director of cricket and former Test captain, has hit back through his lawyer at accusations of racial prejudice contained in a report by an ombudsman
Johannesburg, (APP - UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 17th Dec, 2021 ) :Graeme Smith, South Africa's director of cricket and former Test captain, has hit back through his lawyer at accusations of racial prejudice contained in a report by an ombudsman.
David Becker, former International Cricket Council head of legal and Smith's personal lawyer, issued a statement on Friday in which he disputed findings by Advocate Dumisa Ntsebeza, who headed a Social Justice and Nation Building Commission (SJN) to investigate allegations of racial discrimination in South African cricket.
In a report issued on Wednesday, Ntsebeza found that Smith "failed to rebut the presumption of unfair discrimination" in appointing former Test wicketkeeper and long-time team-mate Boucher as head coach of the national team ahead of Enoch Nkwe, a black coach who served briefly as national team director.
"Some of the findings are entirely questionable and without any basis," said Becker, who claimed that lawyers for "various respondents" had raised "material concerns" about the integrity of the SJN process.
"Important parts of the evidence are simply not dealt with in the report," said Becker.
"For example, the ombudsman states that Smith did not explain why he appointed Boucher in his evidence. However, the reasons are clearly addressed by Smith and (former CSA president) Mr (Chris) Nenzani in their affidavits submitted to the SJN." Ntsebeza also found that Smith's appointment was irregular and that a refusal to report to then chief executive Thabang Moroe, who was later dismissed for misconduct, was evidence of "racial bias against black leadership".
Becker pointed out that Smith did not appoint himself and that his appointment was approved by the national selectors, the entire board of CSA and senior executives of the organisation.
He had worked happily with Moroe's acting successor, who was black, and three black presidents.
Becker did not directly address an accusation of racial bias in the decision when Smith was captain to use star batsman AB de Villiers as wicketkeeper in a Test series in England in 2012, ahead of black reserve wicketkeeper Thami Tsolekile.
But Becker said CSA would have to consider "a number of fundamental flaws" in the process of the hearings.
"For instance, how do you make far-reaching and public findings of racial prejudice against certain people and in the same breath say that they are 'tentative', as the ombudsman has done?"How is CSA expected to implement those findings when the ombudsman has said, by his own admission, that he 'cannot make definitive findings in an instance where the evidence of both the so-called victims and the alleged perpetrators was not tested'?"Why wasn't the evidence properly tested? The ombudsman had the opportunity to cross examine the witnesses under the terms of reference and didn't take that opportunity," said Becker.
Related Topics
Recent Stories
AJLAC announces 5th Conference titled ‘People’s Mandate: Safeguarding Civil ..
Pak-US officials engage to enhance trade, investment ties
IBCC to promote educational excellence, expand regional presence
Pakistani 'Blue Helmets' serving UN Peacekeeping Mission in DR Congo set to leav ..
Putin says plans to visit China in May
US reinstates open internet rules rescinded under Trump
Pakistan embassy organizes scholarship award ceremony in Kathmandu
SC to hear case pertaining IHC judges' letter on April 30
SC orders removal of barriers outside buildings in Karachi
PFA launches crackdown, impose fine for selling expired drinks, food items
ICRC, Rehab Initiative host diplomatic spouses' tour
Azad Jammu Kashmir Prime Minister Chaudhry Anwar ul Haq condoles over the demise ..
More Stories From Sports
-
National Hockey camp to be organized for Azlan Shah tournament
37 minutes ago -
Islamabad Tennis Club demolished by CDA amid anti-encroachment action at public park: Tarar
3 hours ago -
Shayan, Rashid, Junaid to represent Pakistan in U12 Regional Qualifying Jrs
3 hours ago -
Olympic Games Paris 2024: How teams qualified
3 hours ago -
ICC T20 World Cup 2024 trophy unveiled in Islamabad
2 hours ago -
Pakistan to tour New Zealand for 3 ODIs, 5 T20Is next March
3 hours ago
-
Xavi and Barca remain tied in marriage of convenience
2 hours ago -
Pakistan Master Tenpin Bowling C'ship postponed
2 hours ago -
Tennis: ATP/WTA Madrid Open results
2 hours ago -
1st-ever National Sports Revival conference starts next month
5 hours ago -
Usain Bolt named ICC Men’s T20 World Cup 2024 Ambassador
5 hours ago -
Wapda Inter-Unit Kabaddi Tournament to start from April 28
5 hours ago