- Home
- World
- News
- Pakistan slams India & others for inflexibility in their push for permanent seats on UNSC
Pakistan Slams India & Others For Inflexibility In Their Push For Permanent Seats On UNSC
Mohammad Ali (@ChaudhryMAli88) Published February 07, 2017 | 11:40 AM
UNITED NATIONS, Feb 7 (APP - UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 07th Feb, 2017 ) : Pakistan has told the United Nations that the campaign by a group of countries for permanent seats on the Security Council defies the 21st century principle of achieving democratic representation through periodic elections.
Without naming them, Pakistan's Ambassador to the UN, Maleeha Lodhi, was referring to the Group of Four -- India, Brazil, Germany and Japan --who have been demanding permanent membership of the 15-member body for the past twenty years.
"In the 21st century it is inconceivable to establish or run an institution - national or international- which does not embrace the fundamental principles of representation and accountability with periodic elections and fixed term and rotation...", Ambassador Lodhi said on Monday in remarks at the long-running Intergovernmental Negotiations aimed at expanding the Security Council to make it more representative.
"But here we are gridlocked in reforming the Security Council because some among us want a status that defies the basic norms of democratic representation and accountability," the Pakistani envoy said, while asking the G-4 to be flexible in their demand for permanent seats.
Despite a general agreement on enlarging the Council, as part of the UN reform process, member states remain sharply divided over the details. Pakistan, a leader in the Uniting for Consensus (UfC) group, stands for creating a new category of members -- not permanent members -- with longer duration and a possibility to get re-elected once.
But the "Group of Four" have been campaigning for enlarging the Council by 10 seats, with 6 additional permanent and four non-permanent members.
Ambassador Lodhi said there was no disagreement over the demand that the Council should "reflect the realities of the 21st century" to enhance its legitimacy.
"But then some use this disingenuously as an argument to further their self-proclaimed candidacies for permanent seats based on contentious criteria for qualification," she said. "Their claim however does not stand the test of accuracy because many states compete with them and even surpass them in all such criteria," the Pakistani envoy said, adding that the criteria they lay out for permanent seats was exactly the same as provided in the UN Charter for the non-permanent members.
"So, if the criteria is the same, why the difference in character and responsibility?" The UfC, she said, has twice revised its proposal in a genuine spirit of compromise to find a solution that works for all.
"Had there been flexibility in the unjustified demand for permanent seats, many member states would already have played a positive role in the Security Council." Ambassador Lodhi said Africa's demand for permanent seats was different from the individual pursuit by a few countries because it was a consensus demand on behalf of a region.
"Perhaps African countries have suffered the most by the deadlock created by those harbouring a false sense of entitlement," she said. "We believe the African demand can best be addressed in a just, equitable and pragmatic manner through the compromise solution offered by the UfC.
" The IGN process opened on Monday and will continue on Tuesday with the Ambassadors of Tunisia and Romania having been appointed as co-faciliatators of the process by the President of the General Assembly.
Related Topics
Recent Stories
Rock-solid Ruud racks up season-leading win in Barcelona
At UN, Iran says it will make Israel 'regret' reprisals
G7 hears calls for 'critical' Ukraine aid
EU seeks to leverage might to confront China, US challenge
5 Customs officials martyred as their vehicle ambushed by terrorists in D I Khan
Pak-New Zealand match called off due to rain
NHA restores traffic on roads affected by recent rains in Balochistan
China to fully support Pakistan's efforts against terrorism: Ambassador Jiang
U.S. envoy calls on Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar
Poland arrests man over suspected plan to kill Zelensky
EU wants to ease youth movement to and from UK
Police foils attempt of supply mainpuri raw material
More Stories From World
-
At G7, Blinken seeks European support for pressure on China
1 hour ago -
Thousands of Bosnian Serbs rally against UN resolution on Srebrenica
1 hour ago -
Israel assault has turned Gaza into 'humanitarian hellscape': UN
2 hours ago -
Husband of ex-Scottish leader charged over alleged embezzlement: police
2 hours ago -
Ecuador hit by power cuts of up to 13 hours amid drought
3 hours ago -
Hugs or bullets? How Mexico presidential rivals aim to curb violence
3 hours ago
-
Kenya military chopper crash kills defence chief, senior officers
3 hours ago -
Biden hails 'incredible' Kennedy family backing against RFK Jr.
3 hours ago -
Maldives court frees jailed ex-president ahead of vote
4 hours ago -
Probe into Portugal ex-PM Costa appears to collapse
4 hours ago -
Jury selection stalls in Trump criminal trial
4 hours ago -
At UN, Iran says it will make Israel 'regret' reprisals
4 hours ago