US Supreme Court Backs Church Rejection Of Gay Foster Parents
Umer Jamshaid Published June 17, 2021 | 10:58 PM
The US Supreme Court on Thursday unanimously supported a Catholic adoption agency's rejection of same-sex foster parents, in a case that underscored the court's commitment to religious freedom
Washington, (APP - UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 17th Jun, 2021 ) :The US Supreme Court on Thursday unanimously supported a Catholic adoption agency's rejection of same-sex foster parents, in a case that underscored the court's commitment to religious freedom.
The conservative majority and liberal minority justices agreed that the city of Philadelphia should not have excluded Catholic Social Services (CSS) from the foster parents program over the agency's refusal to accept same-sex couples.
The main opinion written by Chief Justice John Roberts focused on the city's contract with foster children placement agencies, saying it treated CSS unfairly compared with its treatment of other agencies.
By not being "neutral," the CSS contract violated the first amendment of the US Constitution, which protects the free exercise of religious beliefs, Roberts wrote.
"CSS seeks only an accommodation that will allow it to continue serving the children of Philadelphia in a manner consistent with its religious beliefs; it does not seek to impose those beliefs on anyone else," Roberts said in his opinion.
The opinion noted that same-sex couples had the option to go to any of the city's many other certified foster child placement agencies.
The case, Fulton v. Philadelphia, had been seen as a test for the right-leaning court on whether religious groups could more broadly discriminate based on their beliefs.
Rights groups expressed relief that the judgment was more narrow than feared.
"The court did not... establish a general right for religious organizations to violate non-discrimination laws," the American Civil Liberties Union said in a statement.
"Though today's decision is not a complete victory, it does not negate the fact that every qualified family is valid and worthy -- children deserve a loving, caring, committed home," said Alphonso David, president of the Human Rights Campaign, which focuses on LGBTQ rights.
While the court's three liberals supported the core decision, four conservatives argued in added opinions that a broader judgement was required that would strengthen the right of religious groups to discriminate based on their beliefs.
The court's newest justice Amy Coney Barrett, a Christian conservative whose first case on the bench was Fulton v. Philadelphia, took a middle view.
She wrote in a concurring opinion that the precedent underpinning the issue of "neutrality" in contracts could be revisited but not in this case.
Related Topics
Recent Stories
US ambassador meets Senate Chairman, discusses bilateral ties
UHS to issue MBBS degrees within three months after final result
Aiman Khan granted UAE Golden Visa
PSX achieves significant milestone, surpasses 72,000 mark
Pak Vs NZ T20I: Orphaned children extended special invitation to watch match
Finance Minister lauds UNDP’s unwavering support during floods
President Raisi leaves for Iran from Karachi
Currency Rate In Pakistan - Dollar, Euro, Pound, Riyal Rates On 24 April 2024
Today Gold Rate in Pakistan 24 April 2024
Punjab CM inaugurates Pakistan’s first Virtual Women Police Station
Dutch model Donny Roelvink embraces Islam
Experts raise concerns over introduction of 10-stick packs
More Stories From World
-
Biden pledges swift weapons delivery to Ukraine
7 minutes ago -
Ukraine attack drones strike Russia energy sites
27 minutes ago -
UK Rwanda deportation law leaves asylum seekers fearful
36 minutes ago -
More floods expected in China's Pearl River basin: ministry
38 minutes ago -
Water release resumes after partial power outage at Fukushima plant
47 minutes ago -
Spain court says investigating PM's wife for graft
57 minutes ago
-
'So hot you can't breathe': Extreme heat hits the Philippines
57 minutes ago -
Thousands in heatwave-hit Bangladesh pray for rain
57 minutes ago -
China-Pakistan Investment and Trade Symposium held in Qingdao
57 minutes ago -
Escaped army horses bolt through central London
2 hours ago -
China to send fresh crew to Tiangong space station
2 hours ago -
Critics fear Togo reforms leave little room for change in election
2 hours ago