![Supreme Court rejects challenge to South Carolina congressional map](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/05/_2/740x404/pic_1716488605.jpg)
Supreme Court Rejects Challenge To South Carolina Congressional Map
Sumaira FH Published May 23, 2024 | 11:23 PM
![Supreme Court rejects challenge to South Carolina congressional map](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/05/_2/740x404/pic_1716488605.jpg)
The US Supreme Court on Thursday rejected a challenge to a congressional map in the southern state of South Carolina that civil rights groups said was improperly drawn along racial lines
Washington, (APP - UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 23rd May, 2024) The US Supreme Court on Thursday rejected a challenge to a congressional map in the southern state of South Carolina that civil rights groups said was improperly drawn along racial lines.
The case touching on the thorny issues of race and politics could help determine whether Democrats or Republicans control the House of Representatives next year.
In a 6-3 vote, the conservative-dominated top court ruled that a congressional district map drawn by the Republican-majority legislature in South Carolina was not an unconstitutional racial gerrymander.
The case was one of several legal battles involving alleged racial gerrymandering -- the manipulation of electoral maps that dilutes the voting power of minorities -- winding their way through US courts.
In the South Carolina case, a three-judge Federal panel ruled unanimously in January 2023 that a congressional district redrawn after the 2020 census was an illegal racial gerrymander and ordered it to be reconfigured before the November 2024 election.
The redrawn congressional map moved 60 percent of the Black residents of the coastal city of Charleston -- nearly 30,000 people -- from one district into another which already had a Black majority.
African Americans tend to vote overwhelmingly Democratic and six of the current House members from South Carolina are white while one is Black.
The South Carolina legislature challenged the district court's ruling and the case ended up before the Supreme Court in October.
The nation's highest court, in an opinion written by archconservative justice Samuel Alito, said the lower court's finding that race was the predominating factor in redrawing the district map was "clearly erroneous."
"Redistricting is an inescapably political enterprise," Alito said, and "a legislature may pursue partisan ends when it engages in redistricting.
"
"Where race and politics are highly correlated, a map that has been gerrymandered to achieve a partisan end can look very similar to a racially gerrymandered map," he said.
Alito was joined by the court's other five conservatives while the three liberal justices dissented.
- Slim House majority -
Justice Elena Kagan called the ruling "seriously wrong" and said it would pave the way for more lawmakers to use race to achieve partisan goals.
"And so this 'odious' practice of sorting citizens, built on racial generalizations and exploiting racial divisions, will continue," Kagan said.
Republicans currently hold a slim two-seat majority in the US House and an increase in the number of Black-majority districts could tip the balance in November's congressional elections, when all 435 House seats will be up for grabs.
Adriel Cepeda Derieux, deputy director of the voting rights project of the American Civil Liberties Union, a party to the case, criticized the ruling as an "affront to Black voters, democracy, and precedent."
"South Carolina's Legislature carved Black voters out of Congressional District 1 for the sake of partisan advantage and weakening their voting power," Derieux said.
South Carolina's is one of a number of congressional redistricting cases being fought in the courts following the 2020 census.
A redrawn congressional map in Louisiana also faced a legal challenge on the grounds it resulted in just one Black-majority district although African Americans make up 30 percent of the southern state's population.
Two conservative Supreme Court justices sided with the liberals in that case and restored a second Black-majority district.
Related Topics
Recent Stories
![Cricket: England v West Indies 3rd Test scoreboard](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/07/_1/235x155/pic_1722019914.jpg)
Cricket: England v West Indies 3rd Test scoreboard
![Finance minister briefs Chinese officials on refor ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/07/_1/235x155/pic_1722019922.jpg)
Finance minister briefs Chinese officials on reform agenda, engagement with IMF
![Finland says Russian vessel violated its territori ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/07/_1/235x155/pic_1722019912.jpg)
Finland says Russian vessel violated its territorial waters
![Olympic opening ceremony under way on River Seine](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/07/_1/235x155/pic_1722019266.jpg)
Olympic opening ceremony under way on River Seine
![West Indies' treble strike rocks England in third ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/07/_1/235x155/pic_1722019264.jpg)
West Indies' treble strike rocks England in third Test
![Ukraine court orders detention of suspect in murde ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/07/_1/235x155/pic_1722019262.jpg)
Ukraine court orders detention of suspect in murder of nationalist ex-MP
![Long queues, ticketing problems ahead of Paris ope ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/07/_1/235x155/pic_1722019015.jpg)
Long queues, ticketing problems ahead of Paris opening ceremony
![Rana Sanaullah Khan joins Paris 2024 Olympics inau ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/07/_1/235x155/pic_1722019638.jpg)
Rana Sanaullah Khan joins Paris 2024 Olympics inauguration reception
![Glowing tributes mark 69th birthday of President Z ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/07/_1/235x155/pic_1722019637.jpg)
Glowing tributes mark 69th birthday of President Zardari at Governor's House
![Players unaware of spying scandal as Canada Olympi ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/07/_1/235x155/pic_1722019635.jpg)
Players unaware of spying scandal as Canada Olympic coach sent home: official
![Naqvi hails Pak women cricketers for going down fi ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/07/_1/235x155/pic_1722019013.jpg)
Naqvi hails Pak women cricketers for going down fighting against SL
!['Sabotage' on French rail network before Olympics: ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/07/_1/235x155/pic_1722019634.jpg)
'Sabotage' on French rail network before Olympics: What we know
More Stories From World
-
Biden talks Gaza ceasefire efforts with king of Jordan
4 hours ago -
Sinaloa Cartel co-founder pleads not guilty after stunning US capture
4 hours ago -
Panama says Venezuela blocked ex-presidents going to observe polls
4 hours ago -
Ethiopia mourns victims of landslide tragedy
5 hours ago -
Khan Yunis fighting displaces 180,000 Gazans in four days: UN
5 hours ago -
Trump slams rivals as he meets Netanyahu in Florida
5 hours ago
-
Obama & his wife, Michelle, officially endorse US VP Kamala Harris for president
5 hours ago -
Rain, cooling slow huge blaze in Canada's Jasper park
5 hours ago -
Airbus and Boeing supremacy secure despite turbulence
5 hours ago -
S.African police detain 95 Libyans at suspected military camp
5 hours ago -
'Slapping therapist' guilty over UK diabetic woman's death
6 hours ago -
Panama says Venezuela blocked flight of ex-presidents going to observe polls
6 hours ago