Charm And Negligence Behind Network Of Master Forgeries
Faizan Hashmi Published February 23, 2021 | 01:30 AM
Paris, (UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 23rd Feb, 2021 ) :A French journalist's investigation into the alleged forgery network around art collector Giuliano Ruffini has also criticised the "great negligence" of art world experts.
The doubts first became public when French police seized a painting owned by the prince of Liechtenstein from an exhibition in Aix-en-Provence in 2016.
The prince had paid seven million Euros at auction for the portrait of the goddess Venus by 16th century Italian painter Lucas Cranach, yet tests would soon reveal that the pigments used in the painting dated from the 20th century.
Ruffini was well-known in the art world. Since the 1990s, he had sold dozens -- even hundreds -- of paintings by such luminaries as Parmigianino and El Greco to some of the great museums of Europe, including the Louvre, often through intermediaries.
Many, he said, had come from the collection of an ex-girlfriend's father, Andre Borie, a civil engineer who helped build the Mont Blanc tunnel.
Vincent Noce, a journalist for The Art Newspaper, points out in a new book, "L'Affaire Ruffini", that no such collection was ever documented.
Noce has spent five years investigating Ruffini's exploits and is careful to insist that he is innocent until proven guilty.
Indeed, much of his ire is turned not on Ruffini, but on the experts who failed to question the lack of documentation around the paintings they were purchasing.
"The most surprising thing is the manner in which museums, gallerists, dealers didn't try to discover the history of the canvases, allowing themselves to be seduced by the finesse of the copies," writes Noce.
"There has been a great negligence among experts and conservators who didn't question the lack of provenance of artworks and were happy to rely on a visual examination -- sometimes just a photograph -- without any laboratory tests.
" For some aspects of the investigation, Noce was ahead of the police, having been tipped off by two of Ruffini's associates after disputes over their share of the spoils.
- 'Charming' - Noce is also caustic about Italian investigators.
Tax authorities, he writes, were surprisingly unsuspicious when they heard of a special oven in Ruffini's laundryroom in Reggio-Emilia, in which a passer-by had spotted a painting left to dry.
A French extradition request for Ruffini to face fraud and counterfeiting charges is on hold while he faces a long-winded tax evasion trial in Italy.
Another extradition request -- for master copyist Lino Frongia, accused of forging an El Greco and other paintings sold by Ruffini -- was turned down entirely by Italian judges last year, claiming a lack of evidence.
Ruffini, now 75, insists he never claimed the portraits were by particular artists, that it was the experts who attached Names and authentications.
He was more than happy to be interviewed by Noce, and was positively "charming" in person, the writer says.
That may explain his decades of success.
"This was a huge affair with dozens and dozens of fake paintings," Eric Turquin, an expert on old masters in Paris, told AFP.
"Ruffini was not able to act without a network of thugs. There were certainly several forgers. They used nicknames, dealt through fake intemediaries, invented provenances.
"It took us a long time, myself included, to understand. Ruffini fooled the great museums and left many victims."
Related Topics
Recent Stories
Currency Rate In Pakistan - Dollar, Euro, Pound, Riyal Rates On 9 May 2024
Today Gold Rate in Pakistan 09 May 2024
IHC adjourns PTI founder, Qureshi's appeal till Thursday
CDWP recommends 3 projects to ECNEC for approval
Tarar assures APNS to resolve issues of newspaper industry
Pakistan urged to capitalize on economic stability, for Tobacco Tax Reforms
N. Macedonia polls set to upend ties with EU neighbours
Croatia's ruling party reaches coalition deal with right wing
Bayern coach Tuchel makes three changes for Madrid showdown
Olympic flame arrives on French soil for Paris Games
Punjab Finance Minister announces expansion of Social Protection Authority's man ..
Kenya inks deal to end doctors' strike
More Stories From Miscellaneous
-
Concerted efforts urged to ease traffic flow on city roads
4 days ago -
Land degradation: A threat to food security
4 days ago -
Revamping health sector, a gigantic task ahead
4 days ago -
American band promotes intercultural harmony thru music fusions
5 days ago -
Waste Management – A persistent challenge for MWMC
6 days ago -
Experts for ending child labour
8 days ago
-
Labour Day - A reminder for better facilities to workers
8 days ago -
Stage Drama Mohabati Manhoon presents in Arts council Larkana
11 days ago -
Wheat farmers in a fix on price, procurement mechanism
11 days ago -
Modern tools to help transform crime investigation procedures
11 days ago -
Sanam Marvi captivates audience with mesmerizing performance
12 days ago -
Modern Education Techniques: A pathway to achieve economic development
13 days ago