- Home
- Miscellaneous
- Pakistan says UNSC has become 'cloistered', calls for improving its working methods
Pakistan Says UNSC Has Become 'cloistered', Calls For Improving Its Working Methods
Mohammad Ali (@ChaudhryMAli88) Published August 12, 2022 | 09:00 AM
UNITED NATIONS, (UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 12th Aug, 2022 ) :A senior Pakistani diplomat has called for restructuring the UN Security Council's 'penholder system" that gives a Council member control over the agenda and drafting of a resolution, as he said the 15-member body was being used by some for geostrategic reasons, putting into question its role to act "on behalf of all UN member states." "Penholder system in essence enables the holder of the pen to take leadership over a situation on the agenda of the Council and to control the structure and core content of a resolution that does not represent the view of UN's wider membership," Ambassador Aamir, acting permanent representative to the UN, said, while citing the August 2021 incident when India, as the Security Council President, denied Pakistan an opportunity to address the Council as a neighbouring country with a direct stake in peace in Afghanistan.
"Such was the case of Security Council's meeting on Afghanistan last year when the President of the Council prevented Pakistan from participating in the Council meeting despite all other members of the Council agreeing to Pakistan's participation at that meeting," he told delegates in an Arria-Formula Arria-formula meeting, convened by Russia, on Thursday.
The format is named after a former Venezuelan ambassador to the UN, Diego Arriva. It is a very informal consultation process which affords members of the Security Council the opportunity to hear persons in a confidential, informal setting.
In his remarks, the Pakistani envoy said the Indian action "clearly demonstrates that the Council has become more 'cloistered', used by some for geostrategic reasons, which puts into question the Council's role to act 'on behalf of all UN member states'." "At present," he said, "the penholders system represents interests of a few member states rather than of all", saying it is devoid of expectations that the wider UN membership has from the collective security system of the UN Charter.
"This situation has given rise to unlawful practices that run contrary not only to the established principles of the UN Charter but also prevent the Council from working objectively," Ambassador Aamir Khan said, pointing out that the most glaring impact was on Security Council decisions that are often drafted in small groups (mostly penholders) and presented as fait accompli.
"We must take cognizance of the fact that the current penholder system lacks the criteria for a fair and just working method," he said, adding that too often the working methods of the Security Council were non transparent, discriminatory and unjustified.
"We believe that a systematic restructuring of the penholder arrangement is essential," the Pakistani envoy said. Penholders and co-penholders should be both from the permanent and non-permanent members, who should engage closely with the countries concerned, fellow Council members, and the relevant departments of the Secretariat, so as to maximize consensus and avert confrontation, he said, pointing out it is a question of Council's legitimacy, its credibility and effectiveness of its decisions.
Not only elected members but also non-members should be involved in Council meetings, he said.
"This also validates our long-held and principled view that the already exclusive and elitist culture of the Council � with outcomes mostly determined by its permanent members � can be changed, not by seating new permanent members on the Council but by enhancing its representatives, openness and inclusive decision-making through the expansion and empowerment of 'elected' non-permanent members," the Pakistani envoy said.
The so-called Group of Four -- India, Brazil, Germany and Japan -- are campaigning for permanent seats on the Security Council, as part of the Council reform, while the Italy/Pakistan-led Uniting for Consensus (UfC) group firmly opposes any expansion in permanent category, and has proposed a new category of members -- not permanent members -- with longer duration in terms and a possibility to get re-elected.
"It is in the interest of everyone to seek a more democratic, effective and credible mechanism for the maintenance of international peace and security through a comprehensive reform of the Security Council," Ambassador Aamir Khan said.
"We believe that Security Council should reflect interest of the wider UN membership."
Related Topics
Recent Stories
HEC reviews curricula for environmental sciences degree programme
ICC Asia looking forward to an action-packed Asia Cricket Week
Yuvraj Singh named ICC Men’s T20 World Cup 2024 Ambassador
Greece hands Olympic flame to 2024 Paris Games hosts
Two Kyiv hospitals evacuating over feared Russian strikes
World must act on neurotech revolution, say experts
Charles & Catherine's cancer diagnoses
Champions Alcaraz and Sabalenka through in Madrid Open
King Charles to resume some public duties during cancer treatment: palace
US defense chief announces $6 bn in security aid for Ukraine
Heavy rains cause damage to Spezand-Taftan railway track
Woman stabbed in Israel, attacker killed: police
More Stories From Miscellaneous
-
Modern Education Techniques: A pathway to achieve economic development
21 hours ago -
Kite Flying: From cultural festival to deadly sport
21 hours ago -
PDMA predicts gusty wind, rain with thunder, hails
4 days ago -
Iranian president Raisi given guard of honour at PM House
5 days ago -
Intellectuals, writers accolades Naseer Mirza on his literary contribution
5 days ago -
Bahawalpur Adabi Sangat hosts memorable mushaira
6 days ago
-
Cattle farming vital to alleviate poverty in rural areas
6 days ago -
Pakistan: A land of tourism, archeological wonders
6 days ago -
Transforming education sector: from job hunters to job creators
8 days ago -
Amjad Bobby remembered on 19th death anniversary for timeless contributions to music
12 days ago -
Legendary actor Nadeem’s 26 films released on Eid-ul-Fitr days in 50 years
13 days ago -
Besant Hall Cultural Centre to celebrate evening with Sanam Marvi on 26 April
13 days ago