Belgium Court Could Throw FIFA Player Rules Into Turmoil
Zeeshan Mehtab Published May 23, 2018 | 05:02 PM
Some of the most important football action of the summer could take place on Thursday not on a pitch but in a Belgium court and could transform the transfer market.
Brussels, (APP - UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 23rd May, 2018 ) :Some of the most important football action of the summer could take place on Thursday not on a pitch but in a Belgium court and could transform the transfer market.
More than two decades after the Bosman case created freedom of contract, ended nationality quotas and shifted power to the wealthiest clubs, a Brussels court will hear an appeal on third party ownership (TPO) of players, which is banned by football's world governing body, FIFA.
TPO allows investors to hold a financial stake in players and cash in by taking a cut when they move between clubs during their careers in lucrative transfer deals. Critics say it deprives players of control over their careers and former UEFA president Michel Platini, now banned from football following a graft probe, called it "a type of slavery".
Football authorities worry that involvement of third party owners with clubs creates conflicts of interest and favours clubs who can afford to form continuing relationships with agents or player owners.
Supporters claim it helps poorer clubs sign and develope young players and spreads the burden of transfer fees because they only buy part of the player's registration. The current case was brought by Belgian third-division club Seraing which in January 2015 signed an agreement with investment fund Doyen Sports based on the potential returns from TPO.
Seraing refused to accept FIFA's ban, imposed four months later, on TPO and has already been fined 150,000 Euros ($175,900, �131,720). Their legal action is supported by the Spanish and Portuguese leagues, who are also taking a case to the European Commission.
- 'Ethical values' - FIFA, supported by European governing body UEFA and global players union Fifpro, are fiercely opposed to TPO. "One leg owned by one, a leg by another, transforming work contracts into financial products," said Fifpro president Philippe Piat.
Seraing's lawyer Jean-Louis Dupont, who also worked for Jean-Marc Bosman when he won his landmark case in 1995, argued that: "Under the guise of protecting ethical values, FIFA are using their regulatory power to promote their own economic interests and those of their ultimate members, the clubs in monopolising profits in a transfer market that they created and regulate." "Why can't players own their own rights?" he asked.
In the traditional model, player registrations are bought and sold by football clubs for an agreed transfer fee. In reality players, their agents and former clubs often receive a cut of the fee as part of the deal, but full ownership of the player simply passes between the clubs involved.
In the interview that cost him his job as England manager, Sam Alardyce told Daily Telegraph reporters posing as Far East businessmenin in September 2016 that getting around TPO rules was "not a problem" and that he knew agents who were "doing it all the time".
Dupont also attacked the independence of the Lausanne-based Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS), which endorsed FIFA's sanction against Seraing. He argued that since CAS is funded by sports federation it cannot be independent. But in March, Seraing lost that battle when a Belgian court of appeal endorsed CAS as the supreme authority in sporting justice.
Related Topics
Recent Stories
Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz Sharif
Govt striving to provide equal education opportunities for all: Provincial Minis ..
US diplomats take part in cricketing activity at Kinnaird College ground
Young maid burnt to death
Commissioner holds meeting on new roti/naan rates, dengue
Russia hits Ukrainian energy sites in 'massive' attack
Series of blessings on bureaucracy in KP continue
New Zealand’s weak team upset Pakistan's victory streak at home
US State Dept Arabic spokesperson Hala Rharrit resigns over Gaza policy
Punjab govt decides to provide free internet to schools across province
Interior Minister assures protection of Chinse nationals in Pakistan
Business community demands reduction in interest rate
More Stories From Sports
-
US diplomats take part in cricketing activity at Kinnaird College ground
19 minutes ago -
New Zealand’s weak team upset Pakistan's victory streak at home
1 hour ago -
US diplomats unveil ICC T20 World Cup 2024 countdown clock at Kinnaird College
4 hours ago -
ICC Asia looking forward to an action-packed Asia Cricket Week
20 hours ago -
Yuvraj Singh named ICC Men’s T20 World Cup 2024 Ambassador
20 hours ago -
Greece hands Olympic flame to 2024 Paris Games hosts
20 hours ago
-
Champions Alcaraz and Sabalenka through in Madrid Open
20 hours ago -
Bagnaia hits back with record Jerez practice lap
20 hours ago -
Greece hands Olympic flame to 2024 Paris Games hosts
20 hours ago -
Shahzaib Rind calls on Deputy Speaker Balochistan
21 hours ago -
Inter-university weightlifting championship kicks off at SAU
21 hours ago -
T20 World Cup 2024 Trophy unveiling ceremony held
21 hours ago