Meta Shouldn't Force Users To Pay For Data Protection: EU Watchdog
Fahad Shabbir (@FahadShabbir) Published April 17, 2024 | 11:35 PM
Facebook owner Meta and other online platforms must not force users to pay for the right to data protection enshrined in EU law when offering ad-free subscriptions, the European data regulator said Wednesday
Brussels, (APP - UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 17th Apr, 2024) Facebook owner Meta and other online platforms must not force users to pay for the right to data protection enshrined in EU law when offering ad-free subscriptions, the European data regulator said Wednesday.
"Online platforms should give users a real choice when employing 'consent or pay' models," the European Data Protection board (EDPB) chair Anu Talus said in a statement.
"The models we have today usually require individuals to either give away all their data or to pay," he said. "As a result, most users consent to the processing in order to use a service, and they do not understand the full implications of their choices."
Meta in November launched a "pay or consent" system allowing users to withhold use of their data for ad targeting in exchange for a monthly fee -- a model that has faced several challenges from privacy and consumer advocates.
Meta has long profited from selling user data to advertisers but this business model has led to multiple battles with EU regulators over data privacy.
The latest announcement came after the data protection authorities of The Netherlands, Norway and the German state of Hamburg went to the EDPB for an opinion regarding the pay-or-consent model used by Meta.
All digital platforms must comply with the European Union's mammoth general data protection regulation (GDPR), which has been at the root of EU court cases against Meta.
The EDPB in its opinion argued that Meta's model was at odds with the GDPR's requirement that consent for data use must be freely given.
"In most cases, it will not be possible for large online platforms to comply with the requirements for valid consent if they confront users only with a binary choice between consenting to processing of personal data for behavioural advertising purposes and paying a fee," the opinion read.
The EDPB also warned the type of subscription service put forward by Meta "should not be the default way forward" for platforms.
It suggested that platforms should consider an alternative that would give users the right to reject being tracked for advertising purposes without the need to pay.
When Meta announced its ad-free subscription model, it insisted it was in line with what regulators and EU courts wanted.
The Silicon Valley company allows users of Instagram and Facebook in Europe to pay between 10 and 13 Euros (around $11 and $14) a month to opt out of data sharing.
Privacy defenders welcomed the opinion.
"Overall, Meta is out of options in the EU. It must now give users a genuine yes/no option for personalised advertising," said prominent online privacy activist Max Schrems.
"We know that 'Pay or Okay' shifts consent rates from about three percent to more than 99 percent -- so it is as far from 'freely given' consent as North Korea is from a democracy," said Schrems.
Related Topics
Recent Stories
Statement of Engro Corporation - LNG Case Decision
Wasim Akram touches fans’ hearts by new look
Empowering women for employment is the need of hour, says Sadaffe Abid
Global study reveals Pakistan’s inadequate measures against Tobacco Industry
Co-Working Center launched in Okara under PITB’s e-Earn program
BHC judges recommend legal action over agencies interference into judicial matte ..
Third Women T20I: Pakistan to face West Indies today
Mahira Khan delights at Arijit Singh’s concert in Dubai
Dubai Customs Celebrates World Intellectual Property Day, Honors Schools and Uni ..
Vivo Reveals Durefishan Saleem as Brand Ambassador for its Upcoming Y100 Smartph ..
FIA investigates alleged irregularities in tickets’ sale for PSL, int’l matc ..
IMF approves $1.1b final tranche for Pakistan
More Stories From World
-
No more dirty diesel for Paris Olympic sites
50 seconds ago -
Pakistan's youth delegation visits Xinjiang, China
11 minutes ago -
'Persepolis' author wins top Spanish prize
11 minutes ago -
White House says Columbia protesters' building seizure 'wrong approach'
11 minutes ago -
Beef industry ignites rural revitalization in Yangxin of China's Shandong province
30 minutes ago -
US panel recommends all women receive breast cancer screening from 40
31 minutes ago
-
European satellite giant SES to buy US rival Intelsat
51 minutes ago -
Former England cricketer Panesar to stand for election
51 minutes ago -
Macron urges Rwanda to end support for DR Congo rebels, withdraw troops
1 hour ago -
Changpeng Zhao, the 'normal guy' who conquered crypto
1 hour ago -
Top French university loses funding over pro-Palestinian protests
1 hour ago -
G7 agrees to phase out coal-fired power plants by mid-2030s
1 hour ago