Top Europe Court To Issue Landmark Climate Verdicts
Sumaira FH Published April 09, 2024 | 02:10 PM
Strasbourg, (APP - UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 9th Apr, 2024) Activists gathered outside Europe's top rights court on Tuesday as it prepared to decide in three separate cases if states are doing enough in the face of climate change.
The European Court of Human Rights, part of the 46-member Council of Europe, is from 10:30 am (0830 GMT) to rule on whether governments' climate policies are violating the European Convention on Human Rights.
All three cases accuse European governments of inaction or insufficient action in their measures against global warming.
In a sign of the importance of the issue, the cases have all been treated as priority by the Grand Chamber of the ECHR, whose 17 judges can set a potentially crucial legal precedent.
It will be the first time the court has issued a ruling on climate change.
While several European states, including France, have already been condemned by domestic courts for not fulfilling commitments related to global warming, the ECHR could go further and make clear new fundamental rights.
Outside the court in the French city of Strasbourg, climate activists including Greta Thunberg gathered to await the verdicts on Tuesday morning.
Bruna Molinari, a member of a Swiss organisation that brought one of the three cases, was also among the crowd.
"I'm 82 and I won't see the effects of the decisions today," she said.
"(But) politicians need to change."
- 'Turning point' -
Corinne Lepage, a lawyer and former French environment minister who is defending one of the cases, said the challenge lay in ensuring "the recognition of an individual and collective right to a climate that is as stable as possible".
That would constitute "an important legal innovation", she said.
Gerry Liston, of the NGO Global Legal Action Network, said the court's position "may mark a turning point in the global struggle for a liveable future".
"A victory in any of the three cases could constitute the most significant legal development on climate change for Europe since the signing of the Paris 2015 Agreement," he said.
The Paris Agreement set targets for governments to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
On Tuesday, Europe's climate monitor said March 2024 was the hottest on record and sea surface temperatures also hit a "shocking" new high.
Even if the European Convention on Human Rights does not contain any explicit provision relating to the environment, the court has already ruled based on its Article 8 -- the right to respect for private and family life -- that states have an obligation to maintain a "healthy environment", in cases relating to waste management or industrial activities.
Of the three cases to be decided on Tuesday, the first is brought by the Swiss association of Elders for Climate Protection -- 2,500 women aged 73 on average -- and four of its members who have also put forward individual complaints.
They complain about "failings of the Swiss authorities" in terms of climate protection, which "would seriously harm their state of health".
In his case, Damien Careme, former mayor of the northern French coastal town of Grande-Synthe, attacks the "deficiencies" of the French state, arguing they pose the risk of his town being submerged under the North Sea.
In 2019, he filed a case at France's Council of State -- its highest administrative court -- alleging "climate inaction" on the part of France.
The court ruled in favour of the municipality in July 2021, but rejected a case he'd brought in his own name, leading Careme to take it to the ECHR.
- 'Right to life' -
The third case was brought by a group of six Portuguese people, aged 12 to 24, inspired to act after fires ravaged their country in 2017.
Their case is not only against Portugal but also 31 other states -- every European Union country, plus Norway, Switzerland, Turkey, the United Kingdom and Russia.
Almost all European countries belong to the Council of Europe, not just EU members.
Russian was expelled from the council after its invasion of Ukraine but cases against Moscow are still heard at the court.
The ECHR hears cases only when all domestic appeals have been exhausted.
Its rulings are binding, although there have been problems with the compliance of certain states such as Turkey.
The three cases rely primarily on articles in the Convention that protect the "right to life" and the "right to respect for private life".
But the court will only issue a precedent-setting verdict if it determines that these cases have exhausted all remedies at the national level.
Related Topics
Recent Stories
Pakistan, China agree to promote cooperation in areas of information, culture
USCIRF’s report as faulty, non-reflective of ground realities in Pakistan: FO
TECNO answers to his Fans!! Price Drop to 55K?
Edotco Delegation Visits PTA
Qatar’s MoS for Foreign Affairs arrives in Islamabad
Seven labourers from Punjab shot dead in Gwadar
Nation will never forget criminals of 9th May who attacked state for politics: P ..
Currency Rate In Pakistan - Dollar, Euro, Pound, Riyal Rates On 9 May 2024
Today Gold Rate in Pakistan 09 May 2024
IHC adjourns PTI founder, Qureshi's appeal till Thursday
CDWP recommends 3 projects to ECNEC for approval
Tarar assures APNS to resolve issues of newspaper industry
More Stories From World
-
Inevitable Madrid continue Champions League love affair
8 minutes ago -
Nissan net profit nearly doubles despite China challenges
18 minutes ago -
Putin says nuclear forces 'always' on alert in Victory Day speech
18 minutes ago -
China's Xi in Hungary to celebrate 'new era' with Orban
18 minutes ago -
Paris Olympic flame begins relay across France
19 minutes ago -
S. Korea vows strong Ukraine ties, smooth Russia relations
38 minutes ago
-
China, France to cooperate on Notre Dame restoration
38 minutes ago -
School's out: how climate change threatens education
38 minutes ago -
Three more Chinese items inscribed on UNESCO Memory of the World regional register
38 minutes ago -
Around 210,000 TV dramas aired in China in 2023
38 minutes ago -
46 pct of Sri Lankan women, 10 pct of school children obese
48 minutes ago -
Japan's real wages down for 24th straight month
48 minutes ago