![Ed Sheeran copyright trial over Marvin Gaye similarities underway](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/images/UrduPoint-English-22.png)
Ed Sheeran Copyright Trial Over Marvin Gaye Similarities Underway
Fahad Shabbir (@FahadShabbir) Published April 26, 2023 | 11:10 AM
![Ed Sheeran copyright trial over Marvin Gaye similarities underway](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/images/UrduPoint-English-22.png)
New York, (UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 26th Apr, 2023 ) :Ed Sheeran arrived at US Federal court Tuesday for a trial over whether the British pop star plagiarized American music icon Marvin Gaye's "Let's Get It On" in his own 2014 hit "Thinking Out Loud." Industry members are closely following the copyright lawsuit as it could set a precedent for protections on songwriters' creations and open the door to legal challenges elsewhere.
It's the second trial in a year for Sheeran, who successfully testified at a London court last April in a case centered around his song "Shape Of You," saying that lawsuit was emblematic of copyright litigation going too far. The judge ruled in his favour.
He arrived Tuesday at the courthouse in Manhattan silently and with his head lowered, wading past the throng of cameras and journalists stationed outside.
At issue in the New York case are alleged "striking similarities and overt common elements" between Gaye and Sheeran's songs.
During the trial, Sheeran told the court "Yes, Amy Wadge and I wrote the song 'Thinking Out Loud,'" referring to the ballad's co-author, said The New York Times, which had access to the room.
The plaintiffs are the heirs of Ed Townsend, a musician and producer who co-wrote Gaye's 1973 soul classic, who were also in court Tuesday.
"I am here for justice, protecting my father's intellectual properties," Townsend's daughter Kathryn Townsend Griffin told journalists outside the courthouse.
"As Marvin Gaye would say, 'Let's get it on,'" quipped Ben Crump, lawyer for the plaintiffs.
Sheeran's "Thinking Out Loud" shot up America's Billboard Hot 100 charts when it was released, and won Sheeran a Song of the Year prize at the Grammys in 2016.
Townsend's family has pointed out that the group Boyz II Men has performed mash-ups of the two songs, and that Sheeran has blended the songs together on stage as well.
Crump pointed to a 2014 fan video showing Sheeran performing a mash-up of his song and Gaye's at a concert, which the lawyer said amounted to a "confession" and a "smoking gun," according to the Times.
The lawsuit, filed in 2016 -- and refiled in 2017 after being rejected on procedural grounds -- also Names Sony.
Sheeran's team contests the allegations, saying "there are dozens if not hundreds of songs that predate and postdate" Gaye's song, "utilizing the same or similar chord progression." "These medleys are irrelevant to any issue in the case and would be misleading (and) confuse the jury." There has been a flood of such copyright trials in recent years, notably in 2016 when Gaye's family -- who is not part of the New York lawsuit against Sheeran -- successfully sued the artists' Robin Thicke, Pharrell Williams, and T.I. over similarities between the song "Blurred Lines" and Gaye's "Got to Give it Up." They were ordered to pay some $5 million in damages, in a result that surprised many in the industry including legal experts who saw many of the musical components cited as foundational musical elements largely in the public domain.
Five years later an appeals court decision confirmed Led Zeppelin's victory over a similar case with the classic "Stairway to Heaven" at issue.
But jury trials over music copyright could go any which way, and in this case likely will ultimately come down to the arrangement of a single chord progression.
A musicologist retained by the defense says in court documents that the four-chord sequence was used in a number of songs before Gaye's hit came out in 1973.
"There's only so many notes and very few chords used in pop music," Sheeran said in an Instagram video last April.
"Coincidence is bound to happen if 60,000 are being released every day on Spotify."
Related Topics
Recent Stories
![Sonakshi Sinha, Zaheer Iqbal's mehndi function p ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/06/_1/235x155/pic_1719046963.jpg)
Sonakshi Sinha, Zaheer Iqbal's mehndi function photos storm social media
![Babar Azam considers legal action over misconduct ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/06/_1/235x155/pic_1719044557.jpg)
Babar Azam considers legal action over misconduct allegations
![ICC approves proposed schedule for Champions Troph ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/06/_1/235x155/pic_1719037963.jpg)
ICC approves proposed schedule for Champions Trophy 2025
![Currency Rate In Pakistan - Dollar, Euro, Pound, R ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/06/_1/235x155/forex-currency-exchange-rates-2.jpg)
Currency Rate In Pakistan - Dollar, Euro, Pound, Riyal Rates On 22 June 2024
![Today Gold Rate in Pakistan 22 June 2024](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/06/_1/235x155/today-gold-prices-in-pakistan-1.jpg)
Today Gold Rate in Pakistan 22 June 2024
![Tribunal seeks election record for 6 constituencie ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/06/_1/235x155/pic_1718993835.jpg)
Tribunal seeks election record for 6 constituencies
![EAD, ADB sign $250 mln promoting sustainable PPP p ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/06/_1/235x155/pic_1718993833.jpg)
EAD, ADB sign $250 mln promoting sustainable PPP program loan
![71st birth anniversary of Benazir Bhutto celebrate ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/06/_1/235x155/pic_1718993832.jpg)
71st birth anniversary of Benazir Bhutto celebrated in Abbottabad
![Mohsin Naqvi condemns IED explosion near security ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/06/_1/235x155/pic_1718993827.jpg)
Mohsin Naqvi condemns IED explosion near security forces vehicles in Karak
![Canal off take from Sukkur Barrage suspended as re ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/06/_1/235x155/pic_1718993562.jpg)
Canal off take from Sukkur Barrage suspended as repair of damaged gates starts
![Sardar Saleem urges Ulema to play role in promotin ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/06/_1/235x155/pic_1718993560.jpg)
Sardar Saleem urges Ulema to play role in promoting peace, brotherhood
![RDA seals illegally constructed factory on 'Lakho' ..](https://photo-cdn.urdupoint.com/media/2024/06/_1/235x155/pic_1718993558.jpg)
RDA seals illegally constructed factory on 'Lakho' Road
More Stories From Miscellaneous
-
Govt urged to take stern action against timber mafia to save forests
6 days ago -
Deosai Plain – A heaven on Earth
6 days ago -
2nd day of music competition takes place
9 days ago -
Cultural troupe from Lahore to renew artistic glory at NAPA from June 27
11 days ago -
Actor Jamil Fakhri remembered
13 days ago -
New reservoirs imperative to avert looming water crisis
13 days ago
-
Govt urged to regulate prices of sacrificial animals
13 days ago -
Historical traditional Jashan-e-Kaag festival begins in Kaag village Haripur
15 days ago -
Playwright, fiction writer Anwar Sajjad remembered
16 days ago -
Well-known personalities paid tribute to Talat Hussain in wonderful words
20 days ago -
Death anniversaries of Rafi Khawar, Mujeeb Alam, Tahira Naqvi observed
20 days ago -
Somia Khan’s new song “Jeetinge Jeetinge World Cup” creates sensation
20 days ago