Defense Says Prosecution Failed To Prove Officer Chauvin's Guilt Beyond Reasonable Doubt
Mohammad Ali (@ChaudhryMAli88) Published April 19, 2021 | 11:40 PM
WASHINGTON (UrduPoint News / Sputnik - 19th April, 2021) The defense for former Minneapolis officer Derek Chauvin said on Monday that the prosecution failed to meet the "beyond a reasonable doubt" criteria in its effort to prove the his guilt in the death of George Floyd in police custody.
Both sides are presenting their final arguments before the jury passes a verdict over last year's incident that sparked a nationwide wave of protests against a racially motivated police brutality.
"I submit to you that the state has failed to meet its burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt," lawyer Eric Nelson said.
Nelson challenged both arguments put forth by the prosecution that Floyd died of oxygen deprivation and that Chauvin used unreasonable level of force in violation of police instructions.
Nelson argued that asphyxia as a cause of death may be incompatible with a 98 percent oxygen saturation level found in Floyd's blood samples. He reiterated that the ability to talk suggests the ability to breathe.
The defense sought to prove that Floyd could have died of a fatal cardiac event caused by preexisting health conditions together with a drug overdose.
Referring to his client as "a reasonable police officer," Nelson urged the jury to review the incident in its entirety, not just 9 minutes and 29 seconds the prosecution chose to focus on.
"Officers are entitled to take into consideration what you and I don't think about... Human behavior can be unpredictable. Noone knows it better than a police officer," Nelson said.
The defense attorney noted that Chauvin was initially canceled from the call, but later summoned for a back up as three of his rookie colleagues struggled to overcome Floyd's "active resistance" and place him in a patrol car. Nelson cited regulations that allow officers to keep suspects contained, confined and controlled until they are no longer resistant. He also mentioned the upset bypassers' crowd who changed Chauvin perception of what was happening and may have prevented a timely emergency assistance to Floyd.
"Compare the evidence against itself. Test it, challenge it, compare it to the law, read the instructions in their entirety. Start from the point of a presumption of innocence and see how far the state can get," Nelson told the jury.
The prosecution sought to prove that the physical force applied by Chauvin on Floyd's back and neck during the arrest on May 25, 2020 caused the African American's death and violated police guidelines. Chauvin faces three charges - second-degree murder, third-degree murder and second-degree manslaughter entailing a maximum punishment of 40, 25 and 10 years in prison respectively.
Recent Stories
Bugti assures transporters for addressing their problems
Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister, Mohammad Ishaq Dar meets foreign min ..
3 drug peddlers arrested, hashish recovered
1496,990 children given polio drops in five days: DC
Six terrorists killed, hideout busted in N Waziristan IBO: ISPR
Pakistan, Qatar agree to further expand trade, investment ties
Sindh cabinet approves Rs177.5m to strengthen, mobilize various wings of police
Faisal Karim Kundi takes oath as new KP Governor
Azad Jammu and Kashmir Prime Minister Anwaar ul Haq Chaudhry seeks more vibrant ..
Tahaffuz Manzil Foster Home providing care & support to homeless children
PCB proposes April 7 -May 20 window; tweaks in rules for HBL PSL 2025
Field hospitals now operational across Punjab: Azma Bukhari
More Stories From World
-
Football: French Ligue 1 results - collated
43 minutes ago -
Football: Italian Serie A results - collated
53 minutes ago -
European Champions Cup semi-final result
1 hour ago -
Football: Italian Serie A table
1 hour ago -
Tennis: WTA Madrid Open results
1 hour ago -
Formula One: Miami Grand Prix sprint race results
1 hour ago
-
Barca have 'huge amount' to change next season: coach Xavi
1 hour ago -
Haaland 'back to business' with four-goal haul in Man City rout of Wolves
1 hour ago -
Newcomer Bellingham Madrid's driving force in La Liga conquest
2 hours ago -
Girona players have made history, says coach after reaching Champions League
2 hours ago -
Reus begins farewell tour while Bayern stumble in Stuttgart
2 hours ago -
Real Madrid La Liga title win in numbers
2 hours ago