CCP Passes Order In Matter Of Alleged Deceptive Marketing Claims
Fahad Shabbir (@FahadShabbir) Published September 19, 2020 | 06:50 PM
ISLAMABAD, (UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 19th Sep, 2020 ) :The Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP) has passed an order deciding a matter of the alleged deceptive advertising claims by M/s Hi-Tech for its products under the brand name "Zic." Chevron Pakistan Lubricants (Pvt) Limited complained to the CCP that certain marketing and advertising claims made by M/s Hi-Tech Lubricants Limited and M/s. Hi-Tech Blending (Pvt) Limited for their lubricant products under the brand name, Zic, were deceptive and in violation of Section 10 of the Competition Act, 2010.
The Chevron also alleged that choice of words such as, "behtreen" in Hi-Tech's marketing claims had created unsubstantiated impression of comparison between Zic and the competing products, said a press release issued by Ministry of Commerce here on Saturday.
The CCP's enquiry found certain claims of Hi-Tech carrying the urdu words, "behtar" and "behtreen" without any reasonable basis and in prima facie violation of Section 10 of the Competition Act. On the enquiry's recommendations, a show cause notice was issued to Hi-Tech and hearings were held in the matter.
Taking into consideration and analysing the arguments from both sides and in light of the Commission's previous judgments and the case law from other jurisdictions i.
e. America, Australia, and India, the bench held that the above-mentioned claims made by Hi-Tech for promoting its products fell under the category of puffery.
'Puffery' is term used to describe wildly exaggerated or vague claims about a product or service that the consumer (in the context) is unlikely to take seriously. Puffery claims are generally allowed and does not warrant enforcement action by the competition agencies, provided that they are not materially misleading.
Moreover, the bench accepted the respondents' arguments that the Urdu word "behtreen" also carrying other meanings such as "alaa", "umdah" or "mumtaz" indicates that the term "behtreen" is general and vague, and not absolute as was alleged by the complainant.
Furthermore, the term "behtreen" is not the correct translation of the word "best" in English, which is an absolute term.
Nonetheless, the Bench held that only the claims, which are objective, quantifiable and capable of substantiation in terms of characteristics of the products advertised would be actionable under Section 10 of the Act.
Based upon aforesaid reason and in view of the net general impression causedby the claims, the Bench set aside the enquiry report and disposed of show cause notices against the respondents.
Related Topics
Recent Stories
Pakistan's progress on tobacco taxation still falls short of WHO guidelines
Man involved in supplying narcotics to students held with 1.48kg hashish
Britain's King Charles III marks first anniversary of coronation
Bilawal constitutes committee to engage with Govt over privatization issue
Crackdown against power thieves intensified in Dera
Federal Ombudsman' regional office holds open court at Paroa Tehsil
Simplification of tax collection, better liaison between businessmen-tax officia ..
Pakistan's satellite mission ICUBE-Qamar milestone in space tech development: Gu ..
French Ambassador lauds Pakistan's role in regional stability
Barrister Naseem Bajwa’s Book "Europe Ki Diary" rekindles passion for national ..
President Zardari arrives in Quetta
Dr Azra Fazal Pechuho visits HM Khawaja Library
More Stories From Business
-
Pakistan's progress on tobacco taxation still falls short of WHO guidelines
1 hour ago -
Pakistan, Japan discuss bilateral cooperation in industry, food security
2 hours ago -
SECP approves PIA’s scheme of arrangement
2 hours ago -
Rupee depreciates by 03 paisa against US dollar
2 hours ago -
Gold rates up by Rs 2,500 per tola to Rs 240,500
2 hours ago -
PSX witnesses bullish trend, gains 862 points
2 hours ago
-
Stocks rise on renewed hopes of rate cuts
2 hours ago -
Rs 520m released for schemes of Wasa
5 hours ago -
ADB reaffirms continued support to Pakistan
5 hours ago -
EU election could force sharp turn in electric car policy
5 hours ago -
Shipping activity at Port Qasim
5 hours ago -
2 plots sealed over illegal construction
5 hours ago